漫画とアニメ

Tue 2007/12/04 08:28 JST
 112
2341 views
一週間の東京 2 title=

みなみけの漫画を買うおうとしたのだが、漫画読んじゃったらアニメの面白い落ちは分かってしまうので、買わないことにした。

一般的に、漫画を先に読んだら、アニメはつまらなくなると思いますか?

このサイトは元JALのエンジニア、アマゾンのウェブサイトマネージャー、マイクロソフトのプロダクトマネージャーそして現在MIRAI株式会社の社長ダニー・チューが書いているブログです。詳しくは彼のプロフィールでどうぞ。
いつも読んで頂いている方はこの挨拶を永遠に閉じよう^^;

This item was posted in the ジャパン category. You can see more of everything else or subscribe via RSS instead.
English English
-Japan Probe - News from Japan (Subscribe)
-Akihabara News – Gadgetry from Japan (Subscribe)

  • zer0alucard
    zer0alucard in the scariest part of the Philippines (Registered on 2007/12/01)
    Vampire

    well if its only the First Volume then its pretty ok ...

    but when you go beyond that ..yeah thats spoilage XD

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:11:55 JST (ID #65922)
    reply to zer0alucard's comment
  • Zarathustra
    Zarathustra in Planet Otaku (Registered on 2007/12/03)
    Student, knife salesman

    It depends on the series really. Bleach and Naruto for example, I'm too impatient to wait for the anime to catch up, especially when there are fillers. Then later I enjoy seeing what I already read animated. And a lot of the time, the anime is completly different (Mai MiME, FMA, Death Note's ending).

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:25:53 JST (ID #65924)
    reply to Zarathustra's comment
  • wildarmsheero
    wildarmsheero in Spaaaaace (Registered on 2006/12/25)
    Lowlife
    http://www.mistakesofyouth.com

    It really depends on the series in question. Some things work better in animation, some don't. Sometimes the animated version just sucks, and sometimes the animated versions are totally different to the point that comparing it to the original is silly (Excel Saga, Pani Poni Dash)

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:26:20 JST (ID #65925)
    reply to wildarmsheero's comment
  • notfair
    notfair in Malaysia (Registered on 2007/08/14)
    Student, ACG Fans
    http://modvisc.blogspot.com

    for me yes, like Naruto and D.Gray Man... but although it is spoil but when (re)watch in anime, quite interesting because got movement + music and etc...

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:28:53 JST (ID #65926)
    reply to notfair's comment
  • tetrflare
    tetrflare in Singapore (Registered on 2007/11/24)
    Spellcaster

    I try not to read the manga for the anime I'm currently following, unless the anime progress too slowly (hint naruto, bleach). Or if the anime ends halfway, like claymore.

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:34:19 JST (ID #65928)
    reply to tetrflare's comment
    • Maiku
      Maiku in Bogotá, Colombia (Registered on 2008/08/08)
      Art Director

      actually im waiting for a second season of Claymore.... also not reading code geass / bleach's manga :P, but im reading naruto manga cuz seems that ill see sasuke vs itachi in 2 years at least on TV.

      Fri 2008/06/13 02:30:40 JST (ID #211834)
      reply to Maiku's comment
  • Ken
    Ken in NYC (Registered on 2007/03/15)
    Student/Writer/Editor
    http://emcreations.wordpress.com/

    Actually, I prefer manga over anime (in most cases). So, I would read it first.

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:46:53 JST (ID #65930)
    reply to Ken's comment
  • SG
    SG in 英国 (Registered on 2006/12/28)
    Art/Media
    http://sgallen.wordpress.com/

    It depends, I read Bleach and Naruto and later watch the animation to see what its like in colour or so. I don't think its spoiling it for me because I've read it (because its my main choice).

    Now, Choice, depending in what is the 'main'. If its animation then do not look at the manga (if the animation is a adaptation of a manga).

    Sometimes its the other way round, Manga adaptation of the animation such as Eureka Seven.

    I normally choose the first come, so I don't have that thing. Unless otherwise.

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:47:50 JST (ID #65932)
    reply to SG's comment
  • Exiled_Gundam
    Exiled_Gundam in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia (Registered on 2007/08/22)
    Castoffable figurines fan

    I usually see both the anime and the manga version. Both sometimes have parts that are present only in their respective version. Moreover, I actually didn't mind spoiler at all.

    p/s: in the manga version, the circumstances where Makoto have to hold buckets with both hands (seen in the opening) is actually different from the OP

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:52:41 JST (ID #65933)
    reply to Exiled_Gundam's comment
  • lostandfound
    lostandfound in Singapore (Registered on 2007/10/21)
    Hikikomori in the making
    http://supermariabros.deviantart.com/

    Well, I don't think is spoils the anime... It actually strengthens your understanding and love for the anime... I'm a die-hard fan of anime, I usually read the manga first before watching the anime, cuz' I can show off to my friends and be the spoiler machine...

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:53:34 JST (ID #65934)
    reply to lostandfound's comment
  • gordon
    gordon in 新加坡 Singapore (Registered on 2007/06/11)
    銀河帝国五〇一軍团 TK/TD 8316 M.E.P.D. Police Sergeant
    http://gordonator.com/

    i remember we have a similar discussion 1 or 2 months ago about manga vs anime.

    personally i prefer manga more. i'm used to reading the manga first then watch the anime. it doesn't bothers me at all nor spoils the fun knowing he storyline beforehand.

    adding on, manga is definitely way ahead of the anime. if i just watch the anime, i'll be very left behind.

    one exception is claymore, i watched the anime first before i started on the manga.

    Tue 2007/12/04 08:57:35 JST (ID #65936)
    reply to gordon's comment
  • GundamJehutyKai
    GundamJehutyKai in Foundation II Stellvia (Registered on 2007/09/12)
    Service desk support
    http://lookingglass.kokidokom.net

    in some situations i think that reading the manga can spoil the anime in some respects but not all. Take, for example, claymore, I found it just as entertaining when watching it after reading some parts in advance. Primarily because it's just different enough when you watch all the fights animated.
    Shows like Hayate no Gotoku and genshiken fare far less well as the anime doesn't really add anything more than what the manga has already shown you (except for that really really homo ep) so it does get a little tedious.

    Tue 2007/12/04 09:01:15 JST (ID #65938)
    reply to GundamJehutyKai's comment
  • nunks
    nunks in Sao Paulo, Brazil (Registered on 2007/09/14)
    Programmer, Student

    I prefer reading the manga first, since the anime is usually an adaptation...

    Tue 2007/12/04 09:20:39 JST (ID #65939)
    reply to nunks's comment
  • Sakari
    Sakari (Registered on 2007/06/19)

    Better to watch the anime first, that way your not as disappointed when its not as detailed.

    Tue 2007/12/04 09:23:37 JST (ID #65940)
    reply to Sakari's comment
  • HMMaster
    HMMaster (Registered on 2007/09/03)
    http://www.khimhoe.net

    manga is better than anime most of the time. so, it is better to watch the anime first. If not, you'll be disappointed with the anime since it is not as good as the manga.

    Tue 2007/12/04 09:31:54 JST (ID #65941)
    reply to HMMaster's comment
  • Coffee
    Coffee in New York (Registered on 2007/07/04)
    Full-Time Otaku

    Though I'm not too crazy about anime as I used to be, my undying love for manga stays the same. (go figure. O.o) So I would only watch a series in its animation adaptation if I *REALLY* like the comic enough. (such as death note & claymore) And even with those animes I eventually get tired of and immediately just revert back to the books... -.-"

    Tue 2007/12/04 10:06:53 JST (ID #65945)
    reply to Coffee's comment
  • DRAGUN
    DRAGUN in Arizona, USA (Registered on 2007/08/22)
    Design Consultant

    I watched Akira (my intro to real japanese anime), and then years later read the Manga. I think because I did it in this order I wasnt annoyed by the huge amount of content left out of the movie. I had no advance expectations. I didnt already have ideas of how their voices should sound, or their facial expressions. Instead, it made me appreciate the storyline of the manga and just mearly notate the missing content in the movie without being frustrated. Plus, the anime score was epic.

    Tue 2007/12/04 11:33:29 JST (ID #65948)
    reply to DRAGUN's comment
  • DRAGUN
    DRAGUN in Arizona, USA (Registered on 2007/08/22)
    Design Consultant

    @LostandFound, I hate guys like you! Ruiner! Lol. The best way to solve someone doing this is a lot of laxatives.

    Tue 2007/12/04 11:34:56 JST (ID #65949)
    reply to DRAGUN's comment
  • Meimi132
    Meimi132 in Stuck in the void between the net life and real life. (Registered on 2007/12/03)
    Student, Otaku, She-Geek(Sheek lol)
    http://meimi132.wordpress.com/

    I like manga better than anime.(Manga is cheaper, you get more story for your money, it may be in black and white in most cases but its so darn cute it hardly matters!!! Who's with me?) So it never spoils it for me. The anime always seems to be a let down... At least thats the case with all the manga-to-anime things I've seen. E.g, CCSakura manga is WAAAAY better than the anime in my oppinion, only thats not the best example, Fruits Basket, the anime was no where near as good...

    Some are pretty much the same, like Genshiken, there are no massive changes to that, and no story-gaps/jumps. The Gals! Manga goes in a slightly different order to the original Manga, but I saw the anime 1st, so I think of that as right.

    I suppose it all depends which you see first, the anime or the manga? It's kinda like the chicken or the egg. Fufufufufufufufu Which came first and which tastes better? lol

    Tue 2007/12/04 11:44:17 JST (ID #65951)
    reply to Meimi132's comment
  • Meimi132
    Meimi132 in Stuck in the void between the net life and real life. (Registered on 2007/12/03)
    Student, Otaku, She-Geek(Sheek lol)
    http://meimi132.wordpress.com/

    @Coffee-san: Here-here!! I started watching the Deathnote anime and it just didnt keep my attention at all... probably because I've already read it and its cuter in the manga lol. Same with alot of manga. Although I must read Ouran to see what the differences are.

    I do the same most of the time, only watch anime I've read as manga before. Although that restricts me somewhat, so now I've got Broadband finally, I can download stuff just to see if its any good, and if I like, I continue. Like with Ouran and Sky Girls.

    Tue 2007/12/04 11:50:56 JST (ID #65952)
    reply to Meimi132's comment
  • Deranged
    Deranged in Loughborough UK (Registered on 2007/02/17)
    Aeronautical Engineer
    http://www.deranged-minds.com/blog/

    Generally, I find that an anime series I have read the manga for feels less exciting as I would have thought. Prime examples are Bleach and D.Gray-Man

    Although I generally enjoy manga more, scanlation is sometimes far and few between, so I sometimes can only see more of it through anime.

    Some manga and anime are done spectacularly in spite of each other, like Eureka Seven.

    Tue 2007/12/04 12:07:22 JST (ID #65953)
    reply to Deranged's comment
  • julieho
    julieho in London/US (Registered on 2007/12/13)
    http://www.thongandbong.com

    I like also like manga a tad bit better than anime.(Manga is cheaper no matter which way you look at it, and you do get more story for your money. The anime always seems have an integral twist in the end.

    Tue 2007/12/04 12:19:39 JST (ID #65955)
    reply to julieho's comment
  • alrick
    alrick in Manila, Philippines (Registered on 2008/01/24)

    for me it spoils the anime especially if the currently airing episodes are filler.. What i do is read the manga as soon as the anime season is over. In that way it's like reading the script of the movie

    Tue 2007/12/04 12:31:20 JST (ID #65957)
    reply to alrick's comment
  • qingy
    qingy in front of the monitor (Registered on 2007/10/05)
    Gunpla Enthusiast

    for me, manga is more true to original story the mangaka wants to tell, whereas anime can contain many fillers that i find annoying (take naruto for example). i think anime adaptations brings double the enjoyment to the original story. in some ways, the manga does spoil the anime, but i think if you enjoy an anime, you should read its manga counterpart too.

    Tue 2007/12/04 12:47:46 JST (ID #65958)
    reply to qingy's comment
  • XSportSeeker
    XSportSeeker in Brazil (Registered on 2007/08/22)
    Dropping computers, starting all over again at Journalism
    http://xspblog.com

    I go both ways!
    Wait, that came out wrong.

    Sometimes I like the Anime more, some times the Manga... some times I like both equally. Like Azumanga Daioh.

    I am kinda sensitive to spoilers, but it's been a long time I read/watch stuff that could be spoiled.

    Like now I'm watching only Lucky Star... there's not much to spoil there.

    But I usually pick only one.. Manga or Anime. And them I'll probably wait a while before getting the other version. So when I do it, it's kinda like remembering how the story went... which is nice.

    I also have the memory of a chicken, so it's not that much a problem.

    Tue 2007/12/04 12:58:33 JST (ID #65959)
    reply to XSportSeeker's comment
  • thefrikking
    thefrikking in Spain (Registered on 2007/08/18)
    Ork Warlord

    In many cases, is not that manga spoils fun, is that the manga IS more fun. Other times, see the anime version gives you other way to enjoy a history,characters or other stuffs. Ah, and don`t forget fan service :)

    Tue 2007/12/04 13:06:50 JST (ID #65960)
    reply to thefrikking's comment
  • Astrana
    Astrana in Calgary, Canada (Registered on 2007/08/15)
    Student

    It depends on the series. for Bleach and Naruto I rather read manga, anime has too many fillers, sometimes there are 2-3 episodehas nothing but endless conversations.

    Tue 2007/12/04 13:09:46 JST (ID #65961)
    reply to Astrana's comment
  • 0rion
    0rion in CA, United States (Registered on 2007/08/23)
    Developer
    http://www.epicwin.org/

    As others have said, for many stories the manga is actually a lot more interesting - shonen stories like Naruto and Death Note being case in point.

    Story pacing and shot composition is often better in manga, and it doesn't deteriorate as noticeably under a low budget.

    Tue 2007/12/04 13:17:01 JST (ID #65962)
    reply to 0rion's comment
  • Pippo
    Pippo in Italy (Registered on 2007/07/03)
    Universitary Student

    generally i always prefer the manga version so i always read the manga first

    Tue 2007/12/04 14:22:34 JST (ID #65965)
    reply to Pippo's comment
  • Hachiko
    Hachiko in Toronto, Ontario, Canada (Registered on 2006/12/26)
    Student
    http://arudesu.animeblogger.net

    The only Manga I bough and read was Negima, and other series that I have not watch before. I usually buy Manga just cause I read it on the way to work or school and have no time to watch the Animated series. Other than that, the Anime's I watch, I never read the Manga from it.

    Tue 2007/12/04 14:38:34 JST (ID #65966)
    reply to Hachiko's comment
  • Tom
    Tom in サウス フロリダ (Registered on 2006/12/25)
    Professional Student
    http://code00101.googlepages.com

    I go back and forth on this one. I only recently started reading manga, but I've been watching anime for a LONG time. Sometimes, I feel like a certain scene was spoiled, but I have noticed the manga is usually better (and this is coming from a die-hard anime fanatic). In the end, I just try to keep saying to myself that it's only an adaptation. I guess it's just a case-by-case situation for me.

    Tue 2007/12/04 14:42:53 JST (ID #65967)
    reply to Tom's comment
  • CMWilly
    CMWilly in Los Angeles, CA (Registered on 2007/04/19)
    Animation
    http://clockworkmachina.com

    sometimes i watch the anime to catch up if ive missed a big chunk in the manga.

    Tue 2007/12/04 14:53:26 JST (ID #65969)
    reply to CMWilly's comment
  • NekokoNeko
    NekokoNeko in Long Beach, CA, USA (Registered on 2007/11/30)
    computer business Infomation system

    I think reading manga does spoils the anime. When I read it, I'll know what to expect and I lose interest in the anime over the manga.

    Tue 2007/12/04 15:14:19 JST (ID #65970)
    reply to NekokoNeko's comment
  • Barsona
    Barsona in Bay Area, California (Registered on 2007/08/03)
    NEET (no, student, AND employed min. wage)
    http://otterhangar.blogspot.com/

    I am a manga-ha, than an anime-ha...
    But they both have their uniqueness... For instance, there are cases in the anime of 名探偵コナン which is not in the manga... The manga of ハガレン definitely is different (in terms of story and character development) than the anime. I recently picked up the スケブ4コマ, and I absolutely adore it. I mean, there are same material as the first few episode, but it was still enjoying to read it.

    In essence, I believe that holding an actual book is much different experience from watching the anime. Therefore, I don't feel as though they are spoiling each other...

    Tue 2007/12/04 15:16:42 JST (ID #65971)
    reply to Barsona's comment
  • reggie
    reggie in indonesia (Registered on 2007/11/10)
    uni student
    http://reggie21.wordpress.com

    i don't think it will spoil the fun.
    cuz there are differences in anime version and the manga version. i do both cuz i want to know the differences on both version. too bad in indonesia. u have to wait for a lone time (usually 1-3 years) for manga to be licensed...

    Tue 2007/12/04 15:50:44 JST (ID #65973)
    reply to reggie's comment
  • kakit
    kakit in Toronto, Canada (Registered on 2007/04/24)
    Student

    Yeah reading manga often ruins the anime for me since I'll know what happens and when there are fillers I cringe. Thus I only read the One Piece manga now, no more anime for that series.

    Also I find myself picking at the parts in the anime that were not originally in the manga and parts that they omitted. T__T"

    Tue 2007/12/04 17:09:58 JST (ID #65977)
    reply to kakit's comment
  • skankywonders
    skankywonders in California (Registered on 2007/08/09)
    Student

    Somewhat yes, unless you've read the manga first, and watched the anime later.

    Minamike, I only watch it when I'm terribly bored, although its actually worth watching and entertaining, love em' sisters.

    Tue 2007/12/04 17:55:02 JST (ID #65979)
    reply to skankywonders's comment
  • decagon
    decagon in California (Registered on 2007/11/03)

    I think it depends on what came first. If it's something from novel->manga->anime, you could lose a lot going from novel (see: Zero no Tsukaima). One reason I didn't touch the either ZnT anime after a few episodes... I think manga would spoil anime if it is more fleshed out, because then the anime would just feel like a rehash of significant events with sometimes insignificant/irrelevant padding between; whereas if only the anime for the series was watched it might be perfectly enjoyable by itself.

    Tue 2007/12/04 18:42:22 JST (ID #65981)
    reply to decagon's comment
  • Raz23
    Raz23 in UK (Registered on 2007/11/19)
    Getting to Japan
    http://raz23.1up.com

    Well I'm very slowly making my way through the Death Note manga, hopefully I'll be done by the time the series comes out in the UK all lovely, dubbed and judging by how long I'm taking a heck of a lot cheaper.

    I'm not sure if I chose rightly now, I hear the anime is even better, hope I haven't ruined it.

    I have to say the Nausicaa anime pales in comparisson to the manga which is amazeringlyfantabulous, so the manga did kind of ruin the anime by being just too darn good, wish i'd seen it first now.

    @ Danny I've started compiling a definitive list and how to guide on DS homebrew apps on my blog if you're interested.^^

    Tue 2007/12/04 18:46:40 JST (ID #65982)
    reply to Raz23's comment
  • silent1134
    silent1134 in Los Angeles, California (Registered on 2007/08/22)
    ???Confused???

    I like reading the manga first since it's the actual storyline and anime only follows to a certain point and mostly ends with an anime original...so it's not really spoiling much IMO...plus it's fun to see how they animate certain scenes...

    Tue 2007/12/04 19:07:26 JST (ID #65983)
    reply to silent1134's comment
  • Ninja Mari
    Ninja Mari in Japan (Registered on 2007/11/06)
    Japanese Student
    http://japanqna.wordpress.com

    Nothing beats Anime Soundtracks, so even if I'd read the Manga, the Anime is still exciting!

    Tue 2007/12/04 19:23:59 JST (ID #65988)
    reply to Ninja Mari's comment
  • Sotb
    Sotb in Malaysia (Registered on 2007/08/22)
    Manufacturing
    http://sotbest.blogspot.com/

    No i dun think so!
    I think the anime spoils the original manga!

    Most of the animation i watch which was converted from manga to anime usually end up with the anime version having crappy story or not as good as the manga!

    Tue 2007/12/04 20:34:09 JST (ID #65999)
    reply to Sotb's comment
  • syrix
    syrix in U.S. (Registered on 2007/03/21)
    student
    http://animesugoi.animeblogger.net/

    I watch the anime first because it comes out before the manga here in the US. But I do find some manga I tend to pick up first and don't mind knowing how it goes before watching the anime as I compare and contrast the two.

    Tue 2007/12/04 20:53:23 JST (ID #66002)
    reply to syrix's comment
  • djet0
    djet0 in Not so Sunnyvale, Teh Golden State (Registered on 2007/01/08)
    High School Graduate... Now what?
    http://djet0.deviantart.com/

    Sometimes there are spoilers, but the best part is when both sides starts taking original only parts. (Like in Keroro Gunso where the whole storyline, if any, takes a different turn than the manga).
    So like they, Anything Goes.

    Tue 2007/12/04 21:14:34 JST (ID #66007)
    reply to djet0's comment
  • Timerswing
    Timerswing in Mexico (Registered on 2007/08/25)
    Student

    You know...It really depends on the person's ponit of view don't you tjink...-_-

    Tue 2007/12/04 21:38:09 JST (ID #66010)
    reply to Timerswing's comment
  • kitsura
    kitsura (Registered on 2007/10/30)

    Depends on what manga and anime. Some of them like Kodomo no Jikan, the anime is crap compared to the manga. If you're like me and have read the manga you wouldn't feel like watching the anime.

    Whereas some of the anime like Naruto are actually quite good compared to the manga.

    Tue 2007/12/04 21:46:48 JST (ID #66013)
    reply to kitsura's comment
  • radical anime fan
    radical anime fan in Singapore, Furnace City, Cinderblock Outskirts. (Registered on 2007/01/25)
    Polytechnic Junior, Bronze Lifesaving Trainee, Mech Designer In-training.
    http://thehangerbay.wordpress.com/

    Not really, but it depends. For me I don't really feel that way except for Midori Days; manga offered more in-depth stuff than the anime. I mean, how much stuff can the producers squeeze into 13 episodes.

    Tue 2007/12/04 21:56:23 JST (ID #66016)
    reply to radical anime fan's comment
  • MumMum
    MumMum in Maryland (Registered on 2007/08/03)
    Retail

    I think what you just did there Danny was rude because the artest who made that manga work hard & did such a great job. In some ways the manga is a bit better then the anime, though the anime is doing a great job right now. Go back an buy the manga!

    Tue 2007/12/04 22:00:06 JST (ID #66017)
    reply to MumMum's comment
  • gordon
    gordon in 新加坡 Singapore (Registered on 2007/06/11)
    銀河帝国五〇一軍团 TK/TD 8316 M.E.P.D. Police Sergeant
    http://gordonator.com/

    as i mentioned earlier, i preferred manga more but one exception is deathnote. i actually prefer deathnote anime over the manga cos the manga is simply too wordy! >_<

    it took me a lot of time to read 1 book! that's why i'm glad the anime only show the important dialogues and left out the not so important ones.

    one more thing, since anime is shown on national tv and watched by children, it tend to be more toned down compared to manga, like nudity and violence.

    take for example in deathnote manga when misa first met kira at his house, we can see her pantsu while she walks up the stairs. we didn't see this in the anime! >_

    Tue 2007/12/04 22:36:35 JST (ID #66018)
    reply to gordon's comment
  • bob-san
    bob-san in Madison WI (Registered on 2007/02/22)
    Administrative Assistant
    http://bob-san.animeblogger.net

    I try not to get too far ahead of a series via manga if I'm really into it.

    And vice versa. My manga vs anime is really dependant on the show. For example, I probably would NEVER have read the Ouran manga had I not seen the series and saw just how the characters were.

    (And still grooving to Hatsune Miku sings "Ievan Polkka" - Going on 15 minutes)
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbbA9BhCTko

    Wed 2007/12/05 00:25:11 JST (ID #66028)
    reply to bob-san's comment
  • まっすぐGO!
    まっすぐGO! in Melbourne, Australia (Registered on 2007/11/19)

    what i do is read up to where the anime is up to. An episode comes out, watch it, then read the manga up to where the episode finished. This is only for series that you would like to watch twice in a row.

    Anime was finished? Check out reviews and see if there are comments like "this is so bad compared to the manga".

    Anime is going to be released in the future? Can you wait a year or two? If it's going to be good, I would wait. If it's unknown, I would read all the manga because manga and anime are generally similar.

    Wed 2007/12/05 03:55:28 JST (ID #66036)
    reply to まっすぐGO!'s comment
  • NeonCloud
    NeonCloud in US (Registered on 2007/05/30)
    College Student

    Ok, I'm going to have to throw in my two cents here. First off, I do believe that reading a manga spoils the anime. I am of course, a much bigger anime fan than I am of manga. However, I personally feel it's much harder to make bad manga than bad anime. I mean, if you feel something is dragging out too long in a manga, you can just read faster. If you want to absorb the story at a certain point, you can stop and think about it, let your imagination go. Plus, considering the multitudes of people out their, with their various ideas of what is good. The freedom inherent in manga lets THEM decide the particulars of a given battle or love scene. They can imagine the minor details as they see fit, creating a more enjoyable environment overall. However, with anime you're more constricted with how you must view the given piece. If the director decides to spend 30 minutes letting Goku charge up, you're forced to watch for 30 minutes. I mean, sure you can fast-forward if you're not watching it on TV, but it's not quite the same as reading a manga faster. Yes, a rather long rant and I havn't even really made my point yet. Basically, I think that an anime is less enjoyable when you already know the story, because people tend to get impatient and feel like too much time is devoted to what they feel is an insignificant event. So reading manga before watching anime is a big No-no in my book. However, the converse isn't necessarily bad. After having watched the anime of a series. Going through the manga at a faster pace is very enjoyable and allows readers to catch things that might not have been in the anime series. Also, it's much easier to skip ahead in manga if you know what happens than it is to skip ahead in anime. Yea, sorry for the long rant.

    Wed 2007/12/05 05:35:32 JST (ID #66040)
    reply to NeonCloud's comment
  • Mafty-Navue
    Mafty-Navue in Jakarta (Registered on 2009/05/17)
    Bored Student/Daydreamer

    Actually I'm quite used to read the manga first and then watch the anime. It does spoil some of the fun since you already know the story (ex. when I watch Minami-ke, since I already read the manga so I already know most of the story and it make me kind of boring watching it). But I don't really mind, since manga & anime has it own feel for me.

    Wed 2007/12/05 07:23:00 JST (ID #66043)
    reply to Mafty-Navue's comment
  • Benjamin Takeyo
    Benjamin Takeyo in Lieu de la batille decisive (Registered on 2007/12/04)
    ひきこもり/Hikikomori. Suits my current state more than a 大学生/University Student. ^^

    Absolutely agreed to NeonCloud's comment.

    Reading manga spoils the anime.

    Wed 2007/12/05 09:09:06 JST (ID #66045)
    reply to Benjamin Takeyo's comment
  • Barsona
    Barsona in Bay Area, California (Registered on 2007/08/03)
    NEET (no, student, AND employed min. wage)
    http://otterhangar.blogspot.com/

    you know what... Just because I can, I am going to argue against my dear friend neoncloud:

    True, that some anime follow the EXACT plot of the manga (Haruhi is a GREAT example of this. And I am pretty sure, for those who read the novel or the manga of haruhi are going to some what figure out what is going to happen in the second season).

    However, there are also anime out there that does not follow the manga entirely.

    some examples of this are:
    -the big Naruto fillers (when you are probably FORCED to read the manga to figure out what happens)

    -Rurouni Kenshin (honestly, the Enishi ark is not even present in the anime)

    -Full Metal Alchemist (they follow a completely different path to the end, while the manga still lingers on about the whole truth of Alchemy)

    -Detective Conan (there are cases in the anime that aren't present in the manga, or in essence, fillers. But it is done in a way that is rather enjoyable, rather than naruto who did filler after filler)

    Even if I read the manga first, and figured out what will happen in the anime, I still don't think it "ruins" it (because you know the story), but rather enhances the experience because now you are watching the manga in action.

    Wed 2007/12/05 13:45:06 JST (ID #66061)
    reply to Barsona's comment
  • tk500
    tk500 in earth (Registered on 2007/11/27)
    stormtrooper

    of course not!! well for example Love Hina i first read the manga and then watched the anime version and to be honest i didn't really like the anime version. the manga is way better than the anime cuz is funnier

    Wed 2007/12/05 14:31:07 JST (ID #66063)
    reply to tk500's comment
  • Henry
    Henry in /usr/bin/ (Registered on 2006/12/25)
    anime/cosplay events organizer
    http://www.cosplay.ph

    it depends...

    sometimes reading the manga doesn't spoil the anime and vice versa. there are times that the manga is differently told ^^

    Wed 2007/12/05 18:28:58 JST (ID #66069)
    reply to Henry's comment
  • Reflection
    Reflection in Australia (Registered on 2007/01/02)
    Anime artist/figure appreciator
    http://www.deibi-manabu.com/

    Nope - it doesn't spoil or ruin it for me in the slightest. I prefer to read the manga first, as I can't really get a hold of the anime easily (or cheap), so I tend to buy the manga first.

    Wed 2007/12/05 22:15:38 JST (ID #66102)
    reply to Reflection's comment
  • Marauder
    Marauder (Registered on 2007/01/10)
    大学生

    I kind of get tired of people always complaining about manga -> anime, game -> manga, etc adaptations. ~_~ (not here but in general)

    Why are you torturing yourself if it's that bad? If you are that bored, go and read some more manga or play another game instead.

    Well that's my 2 cents on the matter. ^_^;

    Thu 2007/12/06 22:35:21 JST (ID #66245)
    reply to Marauder's comment
  • Kaybelrex
    Kaybelrex in London (Registered on 2007/11/07)
    Musician
    http://www.teefonline.com

    I read the manga first then watch the anime.

    Tue 2007/12/11 03:39:31 JST (ID #66566)
    reply to Kaybelrex's comment
  • mavadotar
    mavadotar in Peterborough, Canada (Registered on 2007/12/11)
    Otaku Security Guard

    I think for a lot of people, if they've seen the anime the manga may be too slow paced for them and they might not read it. Personally, I don't care which order I go in, or even both at once, im hard to bore, lol

    Thu 2007/12/13 22:21:33 JST (ID #66917)
    reply to mavadotar's comment
  • Azael
    Azael in New Jersey, USA (Registered on 2007/12/22)
    MEXT Test Taker

    I like both manga and anime. After I read the manga I wonder how they would put the story together in the anime version.

    Sun 2007/12/23 16:33:22 JST (ID #67699)
    reply to Azael's comment
  • ANDRE :D
    ANDRE :D in akihabara! (Registered on 2007/12/19)
    rapist
    http://myspace.com/andreisaloser

    mostly, but sometimes the manga gives even better clues and hints to later happenings than the anime counterparts

    Sun 2007/12/30 08:42:29 JST (ID #68214)
    reply to ANDRE :D's comment
  • shadowguardian
    shadowguardian in Sydney, Australia (Registered on 2007/10/09)
    Customer Service

    Manga is good to read if you are following a anime you enjoy.
    I love when the anime follows the manga close to a "t"

    Wed 2008/03/05 13:38:50 JST (ID #126117)
    reply to shadowguardian's comment
  • Hijiku
    Hijiku in New York (Registered on 2008/01/10)
    Photographer, Chef-in-training, and writer

    I think so. but then again, as holds true with all else, between written and television, there will ALWAYS be some difference, no matter how insignificant or subtle. i prefer to stick with one medium until the end before moving to the other.

    Mon 2008/03/17 18:52:04 JST (ID #157704)
    reply to Hijiku's comment
  • Roddy
    Roddy in currently in Lisbon-Portugal (Registered on 2008/04/14)
    graduate studant (TV & Cinema )

    It actually depends…on the production itself
    There times that the manga (the original story) is better told than the anime script, such as Naruto, Love Hina, Chobits. Even so, if the anime some times is a little different from the manga (well...it is an adaptation after all) is still fun to watch. What really stand out, is the visual and above all the voice production and sound effects that only anime can provide. A good example of that is Evangelion, Furi Kuri, Saint Seiya and even the above citation…come on, there is Not anything cuter that Chii saying Pantsu!!!!!!!

    Sat 2008/04/26 00:04:41 JST (ID #175447)
    reply to Roddy's comment
  • AtelierEdge
    AtelierEdge in Guatemala (Registered on 2008/06/09)
    Artist
    http://www.bridesoferos.com

    After reading the manga, the anime based of it, just (in some cases) disappoints me.

    Sun 2008/06/15 07:17:33 JST (ID #213541)
    reply to AtelierEdge's comment
  • yeah, it really depends. I've got a fair share of surprises and disappointments :D

    Fri 2008/12/26 16:51:39 JST (ID #426175)
    reply to Legionnarion_Conquistadorz's comment
  • lerry[maru]
    lerry[maru] in Kuala Lumpur, MY (Registered on 2008/09/14)
    Nekophilia

    If the manga is ecchi, prolly better to pick up manga since censorship is pwning anime nowadays. (This is always the right choice ^^)

    If not, I prefer the characters speaking and moving. (Thats the usual case, exceptions do exist.)

    I'm thinking of pickin up Minamike manga. Since theres only one season of it. Thats right, season 2 and 3 is just a nightmare guys. It never existed.

    Fri 2008/12/26 16:53:19 JST (ID #426179)
    reply to lerry[maru]'s comment
  • Lelouch Lamperouge
    Lelouch Lamperouge in ClovisLand (Registered on 2008/08/21)
    former Emperor of Britannia
    http://reflectiarx.wordpress.com/

    Majority of the anime studios who create series based on manga tend to rewrite certain parts.
    So overall it's a really different matter if you talk about anime and manga.

    Fri 2008/12/26 16:54:00 JST (ID #426182)
    reply to Lelouch Lamperouge's comment
  • Elrond
    Elrond in Santiago de Chile (Registered on 2008/03/23)
    Programmer

    Yeah, i read Hellsing manga before watching the anime, so i was very excited about what special effects and amazing drawing i were going to watch, but then i feel very dissapointed. The anime version not full my willings, so i prefer to keep the idea of Hellsing about what i read in the manga, wich is so good.

    Fri 2008/12/26 17:40:05 JST (ID #426202)
    reply to Elrond's comment
  • Omu
    Omu in レチウンド島、 スペイン (Registered on 2008/05/13)
    浦の引き篭り
    http://img98.imageshack.us/img98/3219/haruhimemew.gif

    It depends on how much faithful the creators of the anime have been to the manga. If they have ignored the original work a lot, you can even enjoy the Manga and the Anime as if they were indepentent series.

    Fri 2008/12/26 18:19:41 JST (ID #426233)
    reply to Omu's comment
  • pipopaz
    pipopaz in US (Registered on 2008/08/26)
    thousand master II, Internet Learner, Auto didacta
    http://pipopaz.wordpress.com/

    it has happened to me a couple of times

    Fri 2008/12/26 18:21:13 JST (ID #426235)
    reply to pipopaz's comment
  • Hachiroku
    Hachiroku in Finland (Registered on 2007/12/27)
    New media student

    I never think that reading manga first would spoil the ending of the anime. Besides, they often don't even finish those animes I watch or would like to watch. And in most cases manga, which is original, is far better compared to anime produced later. Of course that's not the case always. A good example is Evangelion. First they made anime series, which is great, and now Sadamoto is doing the manga. But they're quite different stories, like to people telling the same legend as they see it. It's impossible to know, how the manga version is going to end. Then there are those new movies. That's the third version of the story. I've enjoyed all of them, so now spoiling there at all.

    Fri 2008/12/26 18:30:13 JST (ID #426239)
    reply to Hachiroku's comment
    • Hachiroku
      Hachiroku in Finland (Registered on 2007/12/27)
      New media student

      Oh, "w" is missing from "two".

      Fri 2008/12/26 18:34:49 JST (ID #426240)
      reply to Hachiroku's comment
  • ale/pepino
    ale/pepino in Fukuoka (Registered on 2008/03/17)
    Webdev, internet contents, music
    http://www.pepinismo.net/

    I'm quite the opposite. I don't watch anime because I've read the manga. Not because it usually comes out earlier but because I like more reading, and I feel it has a more personal touch than anime.

    Fri 2008/12/26 18:35:41 JST (ID #426241)
    reply to ale/pepino's comment
  • Matteas
    Matteas in Prague, Czech Republic (Registered on 2008/10/25)
    High school student
    http://www.animeraku.com

    It depends on the series. When it is good, there is not any big loss in entertainment I think. But you know what will happen next and that means you might enjoy it less. But it works in the opposite way too.

    Fri 2008/12/26 19:49:11 JST (ID #426282)
    reply to Matteas's comment
  • ethoxy
    ethoxy in Belgium (Registered on 2007/09/11)
    physics student.
    http://tldr.me

    Does anime spoil the manga,
    or does manga spoil the anime?

    also first comment since 15 months.

    Fri 2008/12/26 20:16:35 JST (ID #426289)
    reply to ethoxy's comment
  • oOgA
    oOgA in Singapore (Registered on 2007/08/29)
    otaku? lol
    http://www.thebanzaieffect.com

    well, it aint really spoiling. it is just another way of enjoying the story. it depends on how u look at it.

    Fri 2008/12/26 20:28:24 JST (ID #426294)
    reply to oOgA's comment
  • DalGurak
    DalGurak in Lithuania (Registered on 2008/12/26)
    Student
    http://www.japanator.com

    Where I come from, Anime and Manga are quite rare to find but manga has started to become quite popular. So I would say it's better to read manga first then to watch anime.

    Fri 2008/12/26 20:29:15 JST (ID #426296)
    reply to DalGurak's comment
  • Tenshi_MKII
    Tenshi_MKII in Singapore (Registered on 2008/02/26)
    Student

    I beg to differ, sometimes the animes don't follow manga plot(Full metal Alchemist for instance), so it doesn't really spoil at times.

    Fri 2008/12/26 20:39:03 JST (ID #426302)
    reply to Tenshi_MKII's comment
  • askflee
    askflee (Registered on 2008/02/04)

    well i prefer manga than anime in some circumstances but the fact that reading manga spoils the anime is true but i mean i find it that it doesn't spoil it in a bad way (like the quality of the anime or story isnt worse than the manga) its just that these days you can read the whole series witout the slow pace of anime and like people before me said fillers and such....

    Fri 2008/12/26 20:47:04 JST (ID #426307)
    reply to askflee's comment
  • Micchi
    Micchi in Toronto (Registered on 2008/09/18)
    Eroge blogger
    http://omochikaeri.wordpress.com/

    I'd read manga over watching anime since I don't think it'd spoil the plot. Rather, it makes you interested in how it will be animated or if the anime decides to take another approach to it since many adaptations don't follow the manga.

    Fri 2008/12/26 20:49:51 JST (ID #426308)
    reply to Micchi's comment
  • Robostrike
    Robostrike in Waterloo, Ontario (Registered on 2008/01/02)
    System Design Engineering (UWaterloo)
    http://robostrike.wordpress.com

    IMO, if you read the manga, don't watch the anime unless if it is like FMA (the first one) where the story changes. The only one IMO that seems memorable is any anime that have battle scenes that can't be represented with just frames on manga such as Soul Eater and Gundam

    Fri 2008/12/26 21:42:42 JST (ID #426334)
    reply to Robostrike's comment
  • GNdynames
    GNdynames in Toronto, Ontario (Registered on 2008/07/29)
    Student, Bioresearch Assistant, WAVE VP Communications
    http://gndynames.wordpress.com

    I used to watch and read Bleach, I didn't think it was that much of a problem.

    Quite ironically, I find Fate/Stay Night manga to be lack-lustre, but probably because I've played the game first and hence my expectations are too great.

    Fri 2008/12/26 21:56:02 JST (ID #426344)
    reply to GNdynames's comment
  • Deranged
    Deranged in Loughborough UK (Registered on 2007/02/17)
    Aeronautical Engineer
    http://www.deranged-minds.com/blog/

    Yeah, I think it does spoil the anime... Maybe just because I am a Manga Elitist idiot.

    Fri 2008/12/26 22:01:00 JST (ID #426348)
    reply to Deranged's comment
  • soulfringe
    soulfringe in Sacramento California, United States (Registered on 2008/10/25)
    Delivery Driver | Semi-student
    http://www.soulfringe.com/

    This is a very situational question I think.

    In some ways the manga can hype me up for anime. Like current one piece manga arc, I am looking very much forward to seeing animated.

    In other instances I have criticized animes because of how they strayed from the manga, ala Air Gear.

    Then there is just the part were I don't enjoy the anime as much if I know whats already happened/going to happen., which is the more common.

    Fri 2008/12/26 22:14:36 JST (ID #426357)
    reply to soulfringe's comment
  • Hidden Oasis
    Hidden Oasis in California, United Sates (Registered on 2008/10/28)
    College Freshmen

    Yes it does. It makes you realize how bad the anime is. After reading Kuroshitsuji and watching the first episode, I was turned off because the episode took too long (even though I understand you have to do that).

    Fri 2008/12/26 23:07:14 JST (ID #426377)
    reply to Hidden Oasis's comment
  • 聖者
    聖者 in サンノゼ。 (Registered on 2008/02/26)
    フリーター。
    http://www.seizya.com/

    Generally, I read manga more than I watch anime. This is because manga gives me more flexibility than anime. You can read manga anywhere suitable. Anime requires an electronic device.

    Oh. The question. Does reading the manga spoil the fun of watching its anime counterpart later? Uh, yes and no.

    Big "yes" example? "Love Hina". Thankfully, I did it the other way around because if I read the manga first, I would have thought that the anime is just eh at best, not okay. I would stomp on the anime as if there's no tomorrow. (Side note: "Love Hina" is the anime in which I started my love-hate relationship with Iwasaki-san.)

    Big "no" example? "Marmalade Boy". For some reason, I get more interest in watching its anime more than reading the manga.

    Fri 2008/12/26 23:09:36 JST (ID #426379)
    reply to 聖者's comment
  • Freedom Gundam
    Freedom Gundam in United Kingdom (Registered on 2008/02/03)
    College Student

    Well obviously reading the manga will spoil the anime but if your only reading the manga...well then your just reading!

    I personally watch anime despite the slowness and lack of detail compared to manga.
    But watching is easier than reading...

    If you watch the read an old managa you could say that the anime is a spoiler lol 'ergo' it depends on which you prefer but doing both will cause one of them to be worse or ruined.

    Fri 2008/12/26 23:35:14 JST (ID #426398)
    reply to Freedom Gundam's comment
  • Tami
    Tami in Germany - Düsseldorf (Registered on 2007/12/16)
    IT-Architect, SysAdmin, WebDesign and Coding, Virtualization (VMware + NetApp)
    http://www.milkdrop.de/

    Hmmmm, not entirely sure.

    I know that because i have seen the Nodame Paris Dorama the anime version is just rotting unseen on my drive... i mean, i know the story... and thats why i watch the stuff.
    (Besides Tamaki Hiroshi in the Dorama just beats the drawn version by far kyaaaa *^^*)

    But in case of manga... i don't really read mangas, i love to see the things animated with lovely music and so on.

    I must say that Kemeko DX however puts me in a desperate need for the manga since the story doesn't really advance fast enough... for me...
    I mean i really wanna know whyyyy it is all as hoowwwww it is...
    And then they made this... anime... Oo;;
    It's like a gigantic cliffhanger! ><

    Anyways, i think i'm maybe a bit special in that case... or not... hmmmm, not entirely sure!

    Sat 2008/12/27 01:54:55 JST (ID #426438)
    reply to Tami's comment
  • spidr245
    spidr245 in Everywhere, Anywhere, and sometimes There too (Registered on 2008/08/25)
    Ninja / Engineer / Sensei / 魔法少女 (What!?! I can't be, I'm a guy...)

    Reading fills in the gap that the show doesn't. But mostly, I try not to read too far ahead. Then everything is kinda expected and it does become slightly dull when it happens.

    Sat 2008/12/27 03:30:32 JST (ID #426480)
    reply to spidr245's comment
  • speedknight
    speedknight in Singapore (Registered on 2008/11/15)
    NSF(LCP)
    http://www.speedknight.com

    Most of the time i wtach anime first then read manga(or at the same time)
    For me no....
    i have Rozen maiden mannga
    And currently reading toradora borrowed from friend,
    Rozen maiden has a diffrent storyline between the manga and the anime...
    Toradora is much more detailed in the mannga...

    Sat 2008/12/27 04:11:45 JST (ID #426495)
    reply to speedknight's comment
  • eksuterru-kun
    eksuterru-kun in Malaysia (Registered on 2008/12/07)
    Programming Student
    http://greendiscord.blogspot.com/

    i don't think manga spoils anime viewing.
    besides, i prefer manga to anime actually as it's the original stuff.
    and even if the anime is following the manga's plot i still get excited watching it as i want to see it in action with SFX and talking as compared to manga where we read it and are left to our imagination because they can't draw every single frame.

    Sat 2008/12/27 06:31:46 JST (ID #426560)
    reply to eksuterru-kun's comment
  • mavadotar
    mavadotar in Peterborough, Canada (Registered on 2007/12/11)
    Otaku Security Guard

    Really works both ways for me, one is always going to spoil the other a little. But it doesn't really bug me either way, I usually read and manga and watch the anime in whatever order I discover them.

    Sat 2008/12/27 06:57:36 JST (ID #426579)
    reply to mavadotar's comment
  • memoriesoffaddict
    memoriesoffaddict in CA (Registered on 2008/10/30)
    University Student

    Well i think manga is better than anime because they usually make changes to the anime if its based off of something else first such as visual novel, manga, etc., some have little changes while others have major changes. When i read the manga first + if there will be an anime adaptation i usually would rather see the manga plot lines being animated instead of a whole new approach which most of the time is not as good as the manga, etc...

    Sat 2008/12/27 07:26:41 JST (ID #426599)
    reply to memoriesoffaddict's comment
  • FMPhoenixHawk
    FMPhoenixHawk in Michigan, USA (Registered on 2008/01/20)
    Scientist, unemployed.
    http://fmphoenixhawk.livejournal.com

    Honestly, not really. Partly, I don't get manga very often, so I usually see the entire series first, but even when I don't, there's always differences, even if they closely follow the manga.

    Sat 2008/12/27 08:23:10 JST (ID #426634)
    reply to FMPhoenixHawk's comment
  • sanguine
    sanguine in Philippines (Registered on 2008/09/12)
    Student
    http://sanguinerose.wordpress.com/

    I personally think that it doesn't spoil the fun when reading manga first, instead it makes me more curious on how the anime will end up.

    Sat 2008/12/27 10:12:23 JST (ID #426704)
    reply to sanguine's comment
  • Asterisk-CGY
    Asterisk-CGY in Cali (Registered on 2008/09/18)
    TBD

    Eh for Minami-ke, I don't feel there's too much spoilage, since as slice of life stuff there's nothing wrong with expectations. Sure I know what's going to happen, but its different enough with voices and animation that its completely new.
    That said, I saw the anime first, so the manga just added more content to it.
    And I never caught that second series, Okawari.

    Sat 2008/12/27 10:38:03 JST (ID #426715)
    reply to Asterisk-CGY's comment
  • Keii
    Keii in Barcelona, Spain (Registered on 2008/10/11)
    Electronical engineering student

    In my case Gantz anime spoiled Gantz manga. Personally, I think that the worst version is the one who spoils the other.

    Sat 2008/12/27 11:56:07 JST (ID #426771)
    reply to Keii's comment
  • Harts
    Harts in Estonia (Registered on 2008/06/02)
    Student

    For me reading manga usually doesn't spoil the anime because I watch the anime first and then when it is ended read the manga. At least this is how it has been lately. And I like it this way because the manga is usually more detailed and so still interesting to read after watching anime. Of cause there are exceptions to this like xxxHolic.

    Sat 2008/12/27 14:23:54 JST (ID #426881)
    reply to Harts's comment
  • Otaku Blue
    Otaku Blue in London (Registered on 2007/05/12)
    Student
    http://www.otakublue.wordpress.com

    Not really because, its always nice to see how they do the anime to the manga. And a lot of time, to make episodes longer they add filler parts which, if executed well, can enhance the experience. It's cool to see your favourite manga scenes in full motion. Feels like I'm watching it for the first time sometimes.

    Sat 2008/12/27 15:37:00 JST (ID #426909)
    reply to Otaku Blue's comment
  • Sanjo-chan
    Sanjo-chan in Chattanooga, TN (USA) (Registered on 2008/10/24)
    Proud Otaku and Part-time NEET
    http://centakume.info

    Like many have said already, it depends on the series. A personal experience with the manga version of a series is Dragonball Z...I got into the anime pretty good, but by the time I went ahead in the manga, it spoiled it for me. It took me a while after DBZ ended to fully enjoy the manga.

    The newer series like Naruto and Bleach: I'm further ahead of the manga for Naruto than the anime, and I'm further ahead in the anime with Bleach. Fullmetal Alchemist didn't matter for me since it doesn't end evenly with the anime. =P

    Wed 2008/12/31 14:06:30 JST (ID #430880)
    reply to Sanjo-chan's comment
  • Audrey Reiko
    Audrey Reiko in Malaysia (Registered on 2009/02/12)
    Permanent Japanophile

    Manga is normally the original version where the story comes from, so I generally prefer manga over anime.

    With the exception of a few anime where it is nicely done, and that the manga is too messy to read.

    Thu 2009/02/12 05:27:27 JST (ID #485148)
    reply to Audrey Reiko's comment
  • Shisohikari
    Shisohikari in USA (Registered on 2009/02/22)
    Student

    I think reading the manga gives you any idea of what to expect in the anime, also there are some anime that do not even follow the manga all the way

    Sun 2009/03/15 02:15:10 JST (ID #522075)
    reply to Shisohikari's comment
  • warriorsoul
    warriorsoul in USA (Registered on 2009/03/06)
    being a teenager// high school// life

    Actually for me normally the anime spoils the manga... although I personally enjoy reading manga a little bit more than watching anime. But I really love them both.

    Sun 2009/03/15 20:43:18 JST (ID #522922)
    reply to warriorsoul's comment
  • Burai
    Burai in Levittown, NY (Registered on 2009/05/18)
    Student Pharmacist
    http://myanimelist.net/profile/RaRiZaRd

    Here's how I see it:
    If it's a short series with a set episode count for each season, I'd suggest that you don't read. If the anime has mad fillers, then that means it's probably going to be really long. In this case, go ahead and read on.

    I wouldn't read Minami-ke. It's relatively short and you can easily catch up with the anime.

    Wed 2009/05/20 16:49:28 JST (ID #614259)
    reply to Burai's comment

Currently being read