my biggest gripe with this new macbook is the lack of a user replaceable battery. thats not very smart considering its designed for portability and traveling. still, it can fit inside a manila envelope, that's something worth bragging about
Not for me. My main computer is a Macbook Pro, so I pretty much out of the target audience of the Macbook Air. However, I really like the concept. If I had a Mac Pro as my main computer, I would strongly consider the Macbook Air as a mobile extension of the Mac Pro.
Thin isn't always better. Thinner it is the easier that thing is to break.
I think it's impressive engineering and style wise, but I get the feeling that this is more of a slick PDA than it is a series work machine. You do your work on a desktop and just copy the docs to this one and yer off to where ever. My laptops tend to be my man work machine. I'll get a Mac Book Pro later this year.
i'm impressed at the MacBook Air but sacrificing some features like an optical drive and a user replaceable battery for slim factor might give me 2nd thoughts in buying one (as if i have the money to buy one lolz) for US$1799 (or more), i'd rather buy a MacBook Pro with features that i really need like an optical drive or i could wait for a much better MacBook Air in the future ^^ 2008 is the year of Solid State Drives (SSD) ^___^
I'm interested to get a macbook just to learn the ropes of the Mac OS. Currently I got no idea which of the Macbooks to get.... any suggestions for a Mac noob?
Congrats on getting invited to Trend Day! I would prefer sticking to a MacBook Pro for now (And when I get one that is). Will wait for a few years for the prices of SSD to drop ^^; Probably be good to view anime on the MacBook Air while on the plane...
First off, I have the original MacBook and it's still running great to this day, and never had a problem with it. Second, the MacBook Air is not worth it, if I were to honestly see someone, who is outside of a business person who travels a lot, having one of these, I'd just think they been ripped off and/or want to be "trendy". Third, among the Mac community, it's known that you should never buy a first-gen Apple product, as it's almost always due to have problems. Finally, I recommend the MacBook for consumers looking for that notebook, for what you get and price, it's very affordable and terrific machine. As for Danny, Why are the folks using MBP's to run Vista? I assume they just have a dual boot setup on there?
I should clarify my last post a bit more, I meant to ask "why are the people AT microsoft using MBP for Vista?"
To quote one Merlin Mann of 43 folders, "Thinking I've got it now: 'MacBook Air: If you're kinda rich and want a fourth computer.'" If it was half the price of the regular MacBooks, yeah, I'd say it was worth it. But all that removed functionality for the sake of being thin? Last I checked, anorexia is a problem, not a solution. :P
I've recently purchased the Asus EEE for mobile use so the role of mobile workstation is already fulfilled. Granted the Air can do alot more and have much better specs but for a cheap portable for students not using much other than Word, Excel, and Adobe Reader I think EEE is still the perfect laptop. http://eeepc.asus.com/global/ The screen can be improved by cutting the speakers out of course but otherwise I think EE is the perfect mobile machine for me =) (at 1 kg it is also lighter than the Air, even less if you take the battery out)
Not considering, and the reason is here: http://gizmodo.com/345574/is-macbook-air-worth-the-money-five-slim-laptops-face-off I already have a M1330. Might be fatter, heavier, less beautiful (though I don't think it's ugly) and have less battery life but has DVD recorder, memory card reader, HDMI out, Ethernet, replaceable batteries, fingerprint reader, 3D graphics card, upgradeable RAM (up to 4Gb), more HDD space (I really need it), a remote control, 5.1 sound (though it doesn't have optical out), and well... after I installed XP, it's just great! All those are pluses (IMHO) the Air doesn't have. Also, I don't know how hot the Air will get... but the M1330 is pretty silent and cool. Gets warm when you play 3D games though. And I don't really care about showing my laptop to other people. This can be a very dangerous thing here in Brazil, so having a laptop that's as discreet as possible is the best option. Probably the best laptop I could get for myself today on the whole market. Oh, Sony SZ series are not a bad option too... I struggled with myself to decide which to get. While Vista Ultimate (preloaded on M1330, sadly) gave me tons of headaches, fortunately I found a way to replace it, and now everything is great.
This is rough because I'm a huge fan of making my machine smaller so I can take it more places. However, the Air would have to be a secondary computer, and that's not currently the way I use my MBP. More considerations reveal that for a small computer, the Macbook has quite a bit more power and isn't really *that* much thicker. I realize that .25" is very noticeable side by side, but the Macbook is already as thin as some of the ultra-small competitors. No Air for me, but maybe someday [either the Air or a plain Macbook] + iMac. For now I guess I need to use the $2700 worth of MBP I bought. Silly distortion field.
Thats extremely thin.... But I'm betting with one wrong move you would snap it in two somewhere...
Gee, Apple, thanx for your size offer, but, I'll stick with your regular MacBook. I hope they don't stop making the regular MacBooks. That'd be a harsh price to pay. Plus this thinness just looks so fragile... I'd pass on this option. It's cool, nonetheless.
Buying a MacBook Air, in the long run, is really far more expensive than a normal MacBook in my opinion. Batteries that last up to 5 hours? I've to buy a battery from Apple after I used it up? Totally uncool, and it costs 100+ USD. Even as Danny said, for presentations, I'd rather get a super light weight notebook than MacBook Air, which I think is really terrible with all those sacrifices made.
Are normal sized notebooks *that* hard to carry around? I mean... is it really worth squishing everything down, having a less powerful PC and paying more for it? Maybe it's just me....
looks alright - great design - don't know about the performance though - great, innovative product
What an oversized piece of crap, pardon my expression. I mean, it doesn't even have the requisite DVD slots or even the HD-DVD/Bluray of the most modern PC laptops, and 1.8GHZ is just laughable. I love their OS's, I hate everything else about it. And they can stop with the silly, 'trendy' approach of marketing except it works for them too well.
Saw it yesterday and straight away thought about you Danny and the original rumour post you did a while back speculating on a ultra thin touch screen Macbook! :) Not going to get a Macbook Air for now. Even though it's sexy, it's just way too expensive for what it is and I've already got a Macbook Pro, which I love and adore. I still haven't taken it in to fix the buggered super drive and the battery dies on me after just 30 mins :(
It looks like you would snap the thing in half if you put it in a bag...
very usefull for traveling.. most usb drives are bigger than a dvd now.. so no problem there.. but no dvds for movies on the flight??? gonna have to get some movies on the shaddy side of legal :D
Aside from the weight, which all students would appreciate (omg, carrying all my books and binders and a 2.4kg laptop is tiring), the inability to replace the battery by myself is probably why I won't buy this. That and the price. It's really a little pricey, especially when you think about the speed and stuff. Other super-thins out there cost around the same, but have faster processing speeds and/or have another USB port. D: Sigh, Apple could've done so much better.
I really think that this new macbook is adorable, but... I see it more than a potential trend than anything else. I just want portable computing power ^^ Still, It's another thing for me to write about on my blog, post ideas just came to mind en masse after days of now knowing what to post, has this happened to some of you before? ^^
@Swordsly. I'm sure the battery is rechargeable after 5 hours. Correct me if I'm wrong. It's when the battery dies after prolonged use or after certain times and needed to be changed, it had to go back to the Apple store to be done. If I was wrong and it lasts only 5 hours, who in their right mind would buy one? $120++ for 5 hours? I'm sure I know more than a way to have more fun in 5 hours than staring at a laptop.
I think it means that the battery will last for 5 hours BEFORE you need to recharge it again. No one would make a laptop with a single-use battery, that would be tragic.
1 time use and you gotta get another battery for $1oo+?! Brr... It's gonna burn holes in my pockets...
Like most new mac products, it does look very nifty and has pioneering technology, but ill give it a miss. Its mainly due to the fact that its a mac! Im happy enough with PCs, and although that mac is super thin, my current new laptop has a 12" screen and is small and pretty lightweight - its definately manageable for on the go computing, and its a fully functioning computer with 3 USB ports, all the sockets and a DVD writer. Functionality over practicality and style, methinks. My brother is a mac freak, so he will definately be getting it though...
First reaction: "Want!". Then I read the specs and though otherwise. No ethernet, no firewire, 1 USB port, no optical drive? A bit too minimalist for my needs. And the battery issue is a deal-breaker. I've lugged my trusty iBook G4 several times around the world, and while it could be a smidgen lighter, it's just fine as a secondary computer and remarkably solid so that I haven't been able to justify a MacBook yet. If I wanted something portable and very light I'd go for one of the non-Apple options.
I'll keep my pro, but the air looks cool.
I've been holding out getting a mac laptop for a while because of the rumor about this and now its arrived im still not sure :P For roughly the price of a low end MBP I could have one but im not sure I can really justify the cost when I could get a standard macbook for less than half the price. Does look incredably nice though and the technology inside it is pretty incredable and is a good indicator of things to come I think.
Woah wait a second, how come they say the blacklit keyboard is useful to work if we're traveling on a plane if they don't let us carry almost anything with us inside the plane? Or did they go back on that stupid law?
While I desperately want a light, compact Mac (carrying a Macbook Pro around for a 4 day congress is no fun), the Macbook Air is just isn't very appealing. I can live without an optical drive (I never needed it except for OS installation) and Ethernet port, but only 1 USB port? That's ludicrous. And it's just freakin' expensive. But on the other hand... 1.5kg... My back tells me I have to get one :)
Maybe one day it will become cheaper and then I can get one but not right now. I would rather save that money for another trip to Japan for summer for next Comike perhaps ^^;
wait until the dust settled, then I will buy it. Too much hype and too expensive at the moment ..
While its amazing thin and light, I'm sure industry standards will catch up soon. I still prefer a windows machine anyday.
Got the aesthetic, but not the guts. We'll see if it calls my name when its actually in front of me.
I still don't like the mac interface at this point. The capabilities is rather limited on it's own. However, it seems we may be an inch closer to having those sci fiction hologram laptops.
I've started to consider buying a mac notebook by the summer only because I'm fed up with how garbage the PC ones have come out to be. Yes, I am a gamer, but I have a nice enough desktop that can be upgraded if needed, and I've always had a curiosity to turn to a Mac. However, the Macbook air defeats a lot of the purpose of buying a laptop, as the user is restricted to installing things on the Laptop via connecting it to the PC/Mac. It's almost necessary in that sense, that a user should have a desktop before even considering buying the Macbook Air, otherwise the notebook would be near useless... That's kind of redundant if you ask me, even if the damn thing is lighter and more compact, Jobs sacrificed too much in that design.
first of all - being a bit of a pc nerd with over 3years of I.T hardware studies behind me as well as building ALL of the six pc's in my house & gaming on most of them id say this has innovation. some of the features like the LED keyboard & stupidly thin size kicks monkey butt. but then the 1 thing that u cant do which they HAVENT mentioned in the youtube video Danny put up is that you CANT swap out the battry yourself. so u cant carry around a spare battry & apple WILL charge you a premium when it comes to fixing your laptop battry problems & also ontop of that you HAVE to send the whole laptop to them to get it fixed which could also mean that they may take a gander at whats on your hard drive when they managed to fix it. who knows? good laptop but flawed customer service
Hey, first off, I finally signed up to your site! I've been a guest here for about a year now, better late than never, eh? Anyway, I'm a big fan of Apple's designs, and This one has really grown on me, at first I didn't like the black keyboard, but looking at the demo of it lit up is making me reconsider...Still i think its way to expensive, I'd go mac book pro, although I guess it depends on the users needs...
As nice and stylish as it seems, I think I'll stick to my tablet. I can draw on my tablet, after all, and I don't have the money to get one.
Macbook air: something to label under "huh?" I'm with the group that says they sacrificed too much to make it slim and also the price just doesn't justify the content. Tho the same could be said about the Vaio TZ. Danny, if you're going to base your presentation on Jobs, make sure you include several "boom" moments. I understand that he only used the term once this year. A shame...
The lack of an optical drive, as well as it having only 1 USB port, along with the fact that it misses a few other features that I enjoy having, means that it's a definite no-buy for me. I don't care if it's the slimmest laptop, all I see is a thin laptop that looks pretty but doesn't do everything that my current laptop does, and it will probably still cost me a lot more.
I don't think it's a bad machine at all. I'm not one to call something "garbage" just because it doesn't suit my particular needs. I think it's downright fantastic, really, and I'd love to have something in that size for trips. But I won't be buying it. For the reduced size, I could put up with no optical audio, having only one USB port, needing an external disc drive... but I cannot do without firewire. I *really* think they could have squeezed a four pin firewire port on there (and then made a killing on adapters to add power for devices that require it, to boot). If it had firewire, it would be my main machine. Since it doesn't, though, I won't be buying it, and it's back to the MacBook Pro for me. And I'm still enraged by Apple's refusal to include a docking port on their laptops (no laptop needed a docking port more than this one).
I think it really boils down to individual needs. I see this machine as something a person that's always on the go, who needs a decent enough machine to work documents with (on the go), using only Wi-Fi for convenience purposes (because he's on the go, hehehe.....). To those of us who are more demanding (download freaks, gamers, graphic illustrators, movie/photo editors, etc.), a different machine would suit our needs. I like the multi-touch trackpad though. I think it's based on this technology. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLhMVNdplJc[/url]
EDIT! EDIT! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLhMVNdplJc My bad.
MacBook Air is like the flagship sports car that draws attention and gets free press for the car maker. Most people are still going to buy MacBooks and MacBook Pros. Best feature? Multi-touch track pad...drool.
I don't really see much benefit that can gain from it thinness. Moreover, the price is not cheap too and the weight is not the lightest. I would choose something slightly bigger, but with more functionality and cheaper. (Dell XPS M1330 :p)
The MacBook Air looks absolutely stunning. I would love to have one and I can really see it's usefulness for people who have a main computer/Mac at home, but need something light and compact for travel. The lack of an Optical Drive and firewire ports isn't going to be an issue for people who don't need them on the go. However, for someone like me, who uses his Macs for video editing and ISP support, I need the additional ports for specific needs. Therefore, though the Air would be a fantastic computer to play with, I have no specific need for it. I would rather spend the extra money for a MacBook Pro, and have the ports I need. In the long run, I really do see this laptop making a name for itself and selling extremely well. And the battery issue shouldn't be a problem for about 2 years anyhow. Oh, and for those worried about replacing the battery, keep an eye on www.ifixit.com. They will carry replacement guides once they get their hands on a MacBook Air. ifixit.com has the best visual guides on the internet, IMO, and batteries will eventually be available from them and OtherWorldComputing.com for a bit less than Apple's cost. I do battery replacements on iPod ranging from the old first Gen, all the way to the 2nd Gen nano. If you can follow directions on ifixit, you can replace the battery in your MacBook Air.
