I wouldn't mind watching haruhi over and over again... and I don't like Clannad at all
How dare you compare this anime with Haruhi! I'm mad at you Danny, not posting for the rest of the week. *turns around and leaves*
Clannad is that bad?
There was one episode in Haruhi where most of it was a camera in the corner of the room looking down at Yuki sitting in a chair - I thought that was pretty bad.
Come on guys! Clannad is a good series.
I don't believe what I'm hearing... how can you guys NOT like this series? Did you actually give it a chance to go passed episode 1? It's got humour, drama, great visuals, an amazing soundtrack, and one of the most interesting combos of character personalities I've seen in a while. I don't know about comparing it to Haruhi since it kind of stands on its own in terms of genre but this series definitely isn't one to be missed. In my opinion, excluding sequels, it was the best series that started airing last month.
I think Clannad is ok, its very similar to Kanon in my opinion though I'd probably pick Kanon over Clannad. But between Haruhi and Clannad I would definitely choose Haruhi.
I thought; damn this is better than haruhi. But then i scrolled past the images of bread in a can, and I have lost faith. Haruhi remains undefeated. On a series note, I like haruhi simply because its a punch of comedy; whereas clannad looks more of a romance first with comedy taking shotgun.
comparing haruhi to clannad is like comparing apples to oranges. they're both good, and you should watch both of them. this is one of the better animes this season, nagisa-chan ftw.
Hmmm, for me, "Haruhi", while unique, loses to "Lucky Star" in its own brand of high-school humor and parody (also Kyoto Animation) while "Clannad" (rather slow so far) loses to "Kanon" (yet another Kyoto) in music, pace and drama... But out of all 4 of these quality Kyoto productions (or 5 if you include "Air TV"), then "Kanon" is the ultimate overall winnah across all departments. In any case, without question, Kyoto has been one hell of a kick-ass studio! =)
The story in Haruhi is more mind blowing than Clannad, so I give Haruhi some edge. But Clannad is pretty good on its own. It's one of the better school life series that's on right now compared to Kimi Kiss & Myself; Yourself. Kimi Kiss character design is gorgeous though!
Haruhi.. since I didn't start watching Clannad yet. :P But it is on my priority list. Problem is, I didn't manage to finish watching Lucky Star yet, and there's already like 5 animes on my priority list. One of them is Minami-ke. I even began buying Mangas now because it's easier and quicker to read them than stopping to watch animes. :P
It's interesting that so many people say Kanon and Clannad are similar. I understand the comparison and agree to a point. I just didn't care for Kanon... Clannad is slow at time, but I really enjoy the humor and the show is visually soothing for me. That goes beyond the moe girls. Haruhi is non-stop in your face humor. Without a doubt that is what I enjoy about the series. Although right now, Clannad and Minamike are what I need the most.
P.S. Oops, almost forgot... Even if "Clannad" turns out to be an awesome "Kanon"-esque story, what irks me most is "Clannad"s off-key opening tune. Ouch, my ears! Hence, I can never give it 5 of 5 stars. ^_^;;
I'd vote for Haruhi, I think the basic story is imaginative. Despite my preference, I'm enjoying Clannad a lot, although it seems less of an "event" than Kanon. So far, I like all of the girls equally
I stopped watching Clannad mostly because I'm afraid of a sad ending since most of endings in the game are really sad and I'm not going to spoil. I'll re-watch it when the series are over and hope for a normal or happy ending
i really enjoy the humor in clannad much more than haruhi.
ROFLMAO! Those 'game screen' pics are really enticing me to watch lol. Will check it out!
wow, i love to watch clannad, I prefer clannad more than Haruhi :p. Hope the ending not that sad....
I do choose Clannad over Haruhi though. Been a great fan of Key's visual novels-turned-animes.
Yay for Dangos. Awsome series I have to say, quite similar to Kanon. Me likey =)
I am currently on "anime series addiction mode" and following many at once. The reason why I would give Clannad a try is because I find those Street-Fighter-esque screenshots insane. Hope the style, story and characters will be good too. Yes, I will give it a chance in due time. For now, there is a lot of catch-up for me to do in terms of series. See you all later! ;)
Too much clannad plot for mi taste, especially with the ayu plot.
Clannad is just a rip-off from Kanon, nothing more, nothing less
'game screen' pic is especially awesome if you played Little Busters: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Little_Busters%21_fighting_mode.jpg
Danny, you should also check out Bamboo Blade. Another fun comedy with a lot of cute girls.
Clannad is greatness But Haruhi is ALL OF AWESOMENESS INCARNATE! nuff said
I come, i watch, i say Booooriiinngggggg....... Too much romance anime nowadays.
I'm currently watching it when subs are released. The reason I like this anime is because of Nagisa and Fuko.
the girls that i love at Clannad are...ALL OF THEM!!! XDDD but i like Tomoyo, Kotomi and Kyou *heart heart heart*
Danny: the question a bit unfair - its just too hard to answer =) Both series are animated from Kyoto but are great because of very different reasons. If I had to give an answer, I'd say Haruhi, but I'd put AIR over both choices. By the way, if you like Clannad, I really suggest going back some seasons and check out Kanon (2006) and AIR (2004). Both anime are Kyoto Animation adaptations of games coming from the same company (Key). Crev: how can you say that Clannad is a rip-off of Kanon? Both stories come from the same company so its logical they have similar elements. Why don't we stretch it and say that Kanon is a ripoff of AIR?
I'm a Haruhi fanboy all the way. Clannad is a decent show, Fuko especially is an awesome character but I just cannot see it toppling Haruhi in terms of awesomeness. In my opinion, nothing will ever come close to Haruhi :D
I wasn't ever able to force myself to watch this thing, because the only Clannad I know and approve of, is an Irish music group, an anytime somebody mentions this anime online, the I can't think of a ripoff. Also, Haruhi is total oposite, so I voted for HSnY.
I think Clannad and Haruhi are both great! If you do not know, the director of Haruhi is directing Clannad. Just so you all know.
jebus, look at all those screenshots. did you see kanon and air? they were also good, in fact i liked them better.
The only *romance anime I ever found interesting was His/Her Cirucumstance. Damn Gainax! Why couldn't they come to an agreement with so they could finish it properly. So I guess it goes without saying: HarihISM!!1!one!
clannad's pretty much on the top of my watch list right now, i'm usually the first among my friends to watch the latest weekly episode... 'love them Key series.
Clannad NOW! Haruhi season two LATER! Fuuko's my darling. Although Nagisa has the cutest voice, winning by a margin over Fuuko and Kotomi, who has the best knees ever.
(Hope you're okay with others posting youtube links when it's this relevant.) But, why choose when you could have both at the same time? http://youtube.com/watch?v=k2534LehH4s
I can't choose!!! the clannad bread could do with some repackaging and representation.
Nice to know that u are watching it :D. Fuuko rules!!!
Needs moar Suzumiya!!
I love both shows, Minami-ke and Clannad, as well. My favourite characters in Clannad are at the moment: Tomoyo/Kyou and the one that is voiced by the same actor as Chidori Kaname of FMP, don't remember the name, I'm afraid.
I'm watching clannad but it's definitely in the "meh" category for me. there's nothing wrong with it, I'm just not a fan, yet I'm watching it regardless... The beatings Tomoyo gives out are pretty funny tho. Minami-ke is definitely worth watching tho.
Haruhi still the best character. But I have to say the Clannad story is really interested and can't wait to watch the latest episode.
I have just been watching CLANNAD not to long ago, on ep 4 i think, and I feel in love with it. Fuko is my favorite. I remember when I made fun of her when she was first introduced when she "Orgasmed" bubbles. I lol'd. Plus she is so dog gone cute!
Haruhi is SUPERIOR! *snarls at anyone who dares to oppose*
Only 2 reasons why I'm watching Clannad: - Mamiko Noto - Kikuko Inoue Aya Hirano and all her stereotypical characters don't come anywhere close to the talent of these 2 VAs. And in terms of anime spinoff of Key games I still prefer Air. All of them are expected to have sad endings so no surprise there. Anime I would rather watch this season: - Taiho Shichauzo Full Throttle - Kaiji - Shakugan no Shana II And come Dec I would have more Kikuko Inoue goodness as Aa Megami-sama: Tatakau Tsubasa opens.
i decided no to vote because i was not able to watch clannad so i looks a real great series a a must watch on my list....i also want to see it because of its of the creator of Air ..so cute^^...and because all the girls over there look really nice.....
I already knew the ED, and I fell in love with it the first time i heard it. Clannad 4 thi way! :3
For those that don't like this, well it's just preferences... it what it means to be different... for me, this anime ranked really high for me... loved the anime and very anxious to wathc the next episodes and wonders will it be a 2 part just like the game... FYI, the part where it looks like a fight between Nagisa and Sunohara is a Parody from Little Busters!. The HUD is exactly the same...
i like clannad ^_^ but i also like haruhi.... can't choose which one to vote lol.
Haruhi was fun :3 But Clannad made me use my facial tissue box for what it was intended to be for ;____;
both are fun.. i'm a clannad fan long ago.. so there's not much to choose lol..
You know...I've watched all the episodes aired, but I don't actually like the show all that much. If it doesn't start to catch my interest more soon I will probably drop it. The pace is too slow for me. >.>
well, Clannad for me is an alternative to refreshing after watch so many action films because the theme wasn't so bad and simple, but on the KEY's (real claimer) game version on it might have a different story. so the whole season would be like Kanon, I think. I recommend you to watch episode 8, something similar to other dramas but this would be very heavy to know.
I agree with you. They all looked cute.
I have to watch this one for sure.
One thing's for sure. Kyoto Animation is conquering the world! .....well, not really, but I think the anime community has KyoAni's productions on top of the watch list. With collaboration with Key's works on one hand, and Haruhi on the other, it's a sure-win. Heck, even I who started my interest in KyoAni's works with Haruhi want to catch up with their other works like Air and Kanon. Still watching Lucky Star currently. I know, I'm slow...
Er-hem, getting back to topic, I expect much from Clannad. I always like hearing the OP and ED themes of anime before watching them. So, I can said, for Kanon 2006 and Air TV, I wasn't that much impressed when I first hear them. However, with Clannad, the OP and ED themes are an instant thumbs up. It's that good. If you ask me if this is better than Haruhi, I will say this: I will definitely be more willing to buy Haruhi merchandise (okay, so maybe it's because I haven't watch Clannad yet) but Haruhi has this theme which is centered around herself, making it easier for fans like me to choose.
To be honest, though I'm a really crazy about Haruhism, I'd say, overall, CLANNAD definitely won Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu hands down. Awesome drawings, awesome story, awesome humour. If this wasn't supposedly, a romance story, I would take it as a comedy. Its humour even beat some other comedy animes.
i got addicted to clannad when i start watching it a few weeks back. love the homour, character driven storyline and of course the girls. ^^;
is that CANNED BREAD!? O______O
I personally think Clannad is better, dont get me wrong though, Haruhi was pretty good^^
